Research

Best Nonprofit Ads, Ranked: What Moves Donors to Give

Best Nonprofit Ads, Ranked: What Moves Donors to Give

For nonprofit organizations, the pressure to make every campaign count keeps growing. Government funding is harder to count on, more issues are becoming politicized, and organizations are competing for a shrinking pool of donors. To help nonprofits compete, we set out to answer a simple question: what separates the nonprofit ads that actually persuade donors from the ones that don't?

To find out, Grow Progress tested 33 TV ads from 14 of the country's best-known charities, including charity: water, CARE, Wounded Warrior Project, World Vision, Make-A-Wish, and ASPCA. Each ad was measured against a control group to see how much it actually moved donation intent, trust, and favorability. With Grow Progress, nonprofits can run the same test on their own creative and know whether it persuades before the media budget is spent. Here's what the data shows.

Download the full Nonprofit Ad Benchmarks Report →

How we tested 33 nonprofit ads

Each ad was tested through its own randomized controlled trial and served to a representative sample of Americans. Respondents were randomly assigned to watch an ad from a nonprofit, or to see a neutral placebo. Then both groups answered the same brand-perception questions. In total, 21,783 people saw an ad and 9,224 were served the control.

We measured each ad's lift on five core outcomes: favorability, recommendation intent, trust, perceived donation impact, and donation intent, plus 13 brand attributes such as effectiveness, shared values, hope, and urgency.

To rank the ads fairly, we looked at the share of headroom captured: each ad's lift as a share of the room left above its control baseline. Raw lift favors organizations that start with lower awareness or favorability. Share of headroom levels the playing field so a well-known brand and a lesser-known one can be compared side by side.

The 10 best nonprofit ads in our benchmark

Ranked by average share of headroom captured across the five core outcomes:

The 10 best nonprofit ads in our benchmark
Average share of headroom captured across five core outcomes
1. charity: water
"Clean and Safe Water"
33.7%
2. CARE
"Visit Us"
32.2%
3. Wounded Warrior Project
"Famous Skyscrapers"
27.8%
4. World Vision
"Bad News"
26.1%
5. Make-A-Wish
"Make a Wish Hopeful"
23.6%
6. ASPCA
"We Go There"
23.1%
7. Save the Children
"Day One"
23.0%
8. Wounded Warrior Project
"And Their Families"
22.8%
9. Special Olympics
"Athletes Are Waiting"
22.8%
10. American Heart Association
"Help Heart"
22.4%

The top ad captured 33.7% of available headroom, while the lowest-ranked ad captured just 3.3%, a tenfold gap within a single category and format.

The gap shows up inside individual organizations, too. charity: water's "Clean and Safe Water" topped the leaderboard, while its "Clean Water" spot captured 13.1%. Habitat for Humanity's strongest ad captured nearly twice the headroom of its weakest. Same cause, same brand, very different results. Without testing, there's no way to know which version you're about to put media dollars behind.

The full ranking of all 33 ads is in the Nonprofit Ad Benchmarks Report.

What the best nonprofit ads have in common

1. They build trust and credibility

We looked at how closely each of the 13 brand attributes tracked donation intent and trust across all 33 ads. The attributes at the top of both lists were the same: effective (0.68 correlation with donation intent, 0.82 with trust), donation will have impact (0.65), shares my values (0.63 and 0.84), and trustworthy (0.62 and 0.81).

An ad that convinces viewers the organization gets results, that their gift will matter, and that the organization stands for what they stand for is doing the relationship work and the ask at the same time. Character and credibility aren't "soft" brand work separate from performance marketing. They're what drives giving. At the other end, humorous or playful creative showed essentially no relationship with donation intent (-0.01).

2. They commit to one tone

Hope and urgency can both be compelling and effective, but not in the same ad. Hope-toned ads captured 27.2% of headroom on perceived hope but only 18.5% on perceived urgency. Urgency-toned ads flipped that almost exactly: 25.8% on urgency, 13.5% on hope.

Each tone doesn't just fail to move the other attribute. It actively suppresses it. "Things can get better" and "time is running out" pull in opposite directions, so a creative brief that tries to deliver both risks landing neither.

3. They lean on hope when the goal is brand-building

When an ad's job is strengthening the relationship rather than closing a single gift, hope is the safer bet. Hopeful ads outperformed urgency-toned ads on every brand metric we measured:

OutcomeHopeful toneUrgency tone
Perceived impact17.7%12.0%
Trust24.2%21.2%
Favorability24.0%21.9%
Recommend intent11.5%9.4%

The widest gap was on perceived impact, the belief that a donation will actually make a difference.

4. When they use urgency, it actually lands

Urgency has a real role in direct-ask creative. It tracks donation intent (0.61) far more closely than it tracks trust (0.45), the widest tilt toward the ask of any attribute we measured.

But aiming for urgency isn't the same as creating it. Among the nine ads built around urgency, the shift in perceived urgency ranged from 11% to 38% of headroom, and two of the nine scored below a typical ad that wasn't trying to be urgent at all. Roughly one in five urgency ads paid the brand cost of an urgent tone without earning the payoff.

Charity advertising example: CARE's "Visit Us" vs. "Every Minute"

CARE gave us a rare side-by-side: two ads from the same organization, measured against the same baseline, taking opposite creative approaches. "Visit Us" is built on hope. "Every Minute" is built on urgency, and it posted the highest perceived-urgency score of any urgency ad in the study. In other words, this is urgency done well.

Outcome"Visit Us" (hope)"Every Minute" (urgency)
Favorability49.0%31.9%
Trust44.2%26.1%
Perceived impact31.0%19.0%
Recommend intent21.7%13.0%
Donation intent15.1%15.0%

On donation intent, the two ads are tied. On every brand metric, "Visit Us" wins by a wide margin. A team that only measured donation intent, or only watched response rates, would call this a draw and miss that one ad is building long-term trust and the other isn't.

See all 33 ads ranked. The Nonprofit Ad Benchmarks Report includes the full leaderboard, attribute-by-attribute correlations, and audience breakdowns from 14 leading nonprofits. Download the report

Who nonprofit advertising moves

Party affiliation barely matters. Democrats (+6.9 points), independents (+8.5), and Republicans (+9.5) all showed similar lifts in donation intent. Well-made nonprofit brand advertising travels across the political spectrum.

Giving history matters more. People who had never given showed the biggest gains in favorability (+10.5 points), trust (+7.0), and perceived impact (+11.0), which is real acquisition work. People who gave in the past year matched them on donation intent (+8.8). People whose last gift was more than a year ago moved the least on every outcome, including donation intent (+5.9).

The lift was still positive across the board. But if reactivating past givers is a campaign goal, it likely needs its own creative rather than a rerun of the acquisition spot.

Applying these lessons to your own nonprofit ad campaigns

The ads in this benchmark were TV spots, but the same principles apply to any distribution channel where you're trying to move someone before paying to reach them at scale:

  • Nonprofit digital advertising. Facebook ads for nonprofits and other paid social are usually judged on clicks and cost per acquisition. Testing tells you which attributes your creative is actually moving, such as trust, impact, and shared values, before you scale spend.
  • Direct mail appeals. Instead of waiting weeks for response rates, you can pre-test your annual fundraising appeal with your target audience first.
  • Email fundraising asks. Subject-line A/B tests measure opens. Persuasion testing measures whether the message changed how someone feels about giving.
  • Brand and awareness campaigns. Replace gut instinct and last year's performance with a predicted lift before launch.

The alternative is learning in-market. A live A/B test means part of your audience gets the losing creative, and every week spent on a weaker ad is money left on the table. For more on matching the message to the audience, see our guide to fundraising strategies for nonprofits.

Find out where your ads would rank

Grow Progress's Rapid Message Testing runs the same randomized controlled trials behind this leaderboard: a real control group, the full attribute read, and results in as little as 24 hours. You'll know which attributes your creative is moving before it goes live, not after the media spend is gone.

Learn more about our work with nonprofits, or talk to our team to see how your ads stack up against the benchmark.